dude....the mattoid is on this bill. holy crap. i have an old mattoid album. it's a cover album from some sorta drunk ogre. he covers dancing queen and it makes me feel funny inside.
i think there is a big difference between amateur and skilled, that's all. nothing here is unconscious or an accident, that's why it's really well done.
On top of it, it's totally great for the band.
balance and sleekness are sometimes overrated, and this expresses more than it would have if it had a sleekness to it. of course, this is just my opinion.