Contructive Criticism Forum

[mibs]

maybe a forum where people can get real crit on something they submit... they are so many good artists on here there should be more of a chance to elevate ones artwork if they want... i think people would take advantage of this...

[John A]

I have an opinion.

[bathroom monkey]

sounds like someone is on a Saturday night bender.

[Jeph]

I should eat more healthy foods.

[andydiesel]

i just finished a wonderful plate of sushi.

[VegetableLasagna]

I just payed the porcelain piper for the movie popcorn and pre-movie fast food from last night. My arsehole. . the burning . . .the burning . ..

Wait, what are we talking about?

[JohnHoward]

Those replies are awesome. They are both off subject and at the same time the most eloquent answer to the suggestion. They are a little skit demonstrating why the idea wouldn't work. Brilliant!

I do find the last post is a little disconcerting the way it flirts alliteration but never fully embraces a particular letter.

overall : Rules!

[DRG]

Those replies are awesome. They are both off subject and at the same time the most eloquent answer to the suggestion. They are a little skit demonstrating why the idea wouldn't work. Brilliant!

I do find the last post is a little disconcerting the way it flirts alliteration but never fully embraces a particular letter.

overall : Rules!

Nail on the head. Unfortunately, this is the nature of GP (and indeed the internet) sometimes.

I clicked on this thread to either offer some crit or to submit a poster of my own... basically, to contribute.

I imagine sometimes that the GP forums are like a radio show - I would say the Howard Stern show but I've never heard it, but something along those lines. We try to get some kind of actual content or discussion together but everyone is trying so hard to throw in their 'hillarious' one-liners, or burp, or fart, or spout non sequiters, or 'be weird in the studio', so the result ends up being off topic gibberish.

Strangely, when I think of it in this manner it isn't nearly so annoying and actually starts to become endearing.

[JohnHoward]

starts to become endearing.

yep heh

[VegetableLasagna]

I'm down for constructive criticism just as much as I am down for fucking around. There wasn't any real dialogue going on on this thread so i joined in the jackassery. I am more than willing to lend constructive criticism.